Here is a good article from Manulife’s Chief Investment Strategists Kevin Headland and Macan Nia about how to survive a bear attack:

The best way of being kind to bears is not to be very close to them.

– Margaret Atwood

2022 has so far not been kind to investors and there has not been anywhere to hide.

We have four simple rules that we like to use as a framework during these periods of heightened volatility. They are loosely based on advice in the event one comes face to face with a bear in the wild.


Rule #1 – Vanquish fear and panic.


When it comes to the stock market, there’ll always be a reason to sell. Negative headlines stoke fear in the minds of investors and that’s a natural reaction from a human behavioral perspective. Loss aversion is a cognitive bias, which explains why individuals feel the pain of a loss twice as much as the equivalent pleasure of gain. As a result of this, individuals tend to try to avoid losses in whatever way possible.

Similar to a bear attack in the wild, corrections can happen at any time. Stock market corrections (a drop of 10% or more) are common and very difficult to predict. Since 1980, the S&P 500 Index has fallen an average of 14.3% in any given calendar year but is positive 78% of the time with an average return of 10.3%! The key is to position an investment portfolio defensively prior to recessions that correspond to large equity drawdowns.

S&P Index – calendar-year and max intra-year returns (1980 – current)

This chart shows the calendar-year and maximum intra-year percentage returns for the S&P 500 Index, from 1980 to December 2021.


Source: Capital Markets Strategy, Bloomberg, as of December 31, 2021

Another cognitive bias when it comes to humans and investing is availability bias, where we tend to listen the most to the information that’s most readily available—like why we tend to read headlines and not the entire news article. It’s important that investors take in all available information and make a sound, informed decision rather than one based on the most sensational headline.


Rule #2 – Know your environment.


Our work would suggest that the U.S. economy has begun to slow down and will continue to do so throughout the year. But let’s be clear: despite the slowdown, the probability of a traditional U.S. recession over the next 12 months remains low. When we say traditional, we mean one that lasts 10 months, on average, and often coincides with elevated unemployment. A technical recession, where GDP is negative over two consecutive quarters, is possible, but we believe a sustained bear market is unlikely.

Historically, there are warning signals prior to falling into a traditional economic recession. Some of the signals that we look at are highlighted in the table below. Other than inflationary pressures, which was already signaling a higher risk of recession, we’ve now seen two other indicators: the yield curve, measured by the difference between the 10-2 year U.S. government bond yields, and financial conditions that have started to signal an economic slowdown. However, the other signs of a recession aren’t present today, which supports our narrative of a slowing economy.


Here’s a table that shows seven signs of a recession and whether they’re present as of March 31, 2022. Of the seven listed signs, only one is listed as being present today: positive inflationary trends. Two signs are listed as neutral: inverted yield curve and tighter financial conditions.

Source: Capital Markets Strategy, Bloomberg, as of March 31, 2022

Although the economic data is slowing, there’s evidence that corporate earnings remain quite resilient. We‘re almost halfway through Q1 2022 earnings for the S&P 500, and 76% of companies have exceeded expectations. Given the negative sentiment today, they’re not being rewarded in the form of a higher share price. In their earnings calls, many CEOs are talking about their continued hiring intentions and the tight labour market. Unemployment in the U.S. is very low at 3.6%, and arguably a level that’s synonymous with full employment. It’s very rare to see recessions when unemployment is this low.

Recession indicator – U.S. unemployment (%) 1954 – current

This chart shows the percentage and three-year moving average of U.S. unemployment from 1954 to March 31, 2022. The chart also indicates periods of recession, which usually occur during periods of high unemployment.

Source: Capital Markets Strategy, Bloomberg, as of March 31, 2022


Rule #3 – Take advantage of opportunities.


For the long-term investor, it’s important to remain focused on the fundamentals. Warren Buffet attributes some of his success to being a contrarian investor. He famously said, “We simply attempt to be fearful when others are greedy and to be greedy only when others are fearful.”  Investors know this investment truism to be accurate but it’s often hard to execute.

The VIX Index is a great measure of the amount of fear in the markets. When the VIX index is high, there’s more fear amongst investors. Since 1990, the VIX has averaged approximately 19, and a measure above 30 is an important level that signifies extreme aversion to equities.

The VIX is once again above 30. Historically, when the VIX has breached 30, the S&P 500 Price Index return has been positive more than 80% of the time one year later.

The table below contrasts six-month, one-year, and two-year annualized returns for the S&P 500 Index since 1990 in periods when the VIX is greater than 30, in periods when the VIX is less than 30, and in all periods combined. History suggests that investors can improve their returns by becoming greedy and embracing risk when others are fearful and selling. However, in this environment, it’s also important to take advantage of the right opportunities. This isn’t a time to add to the higher risk areas of the market but rather to be selective.

S&P 500 Index – six-month, one-year, and two-year* (CAGR) forward returns (1990 – current)

Here’s a chart that compares the six-month, one-year, and two-year annualized returns for the S&P 500 Index, from 1990 to February 2022, in periods when the VIX is greater than 30, in periods when the VIX is less than 30, and in all periods combined.

Source: Capital Market Strategy, as of February 28, 2022

When it comes to predicting the number of U.S. Federal Reserve rate hikes, the market is notoriously bad at it. During most rate-hike cycles, the market tends to be overly aggressive in its expectations for the number of rate hikes by the Fed at the beginning of the cycle. Market expectations are for the Fed to raise the overnight interest rate a total of ten times over the next seven meetings leaving the Federal Funds Rate near 3% after the February 1, 2023 meeting. Should we see weaker economic data, it could give enough reason for them to pivot from their ultra-hawkish tone. Any shift in that tone to a less hawkish stance would likely be positive for both equities and fixed income.


Rule #4 – Don’t be afraid of what goes bump in the night. If something is meant to harm you, it’ll stalk you silently.


There’s another behavioral bias called confirmation bias. This is where investors seek out information to prove their beliefs. If they’re worried about the economy or markets, they’ll look for articles or comments on the internet, social media, TV, or elsewhere that helps support their fears. They won’t look for information that’ll help calm their fears. While it’s important to not dismiss the fears, it’s important to gather all information to come to an informed decision. It’s likely that what they believe will cause the next recession and/or bear market won’t be the main catalyst; it’s likely to be something completely different.


Our final thoughts—don’t run


The data is showing a slowdown in the U.S. economy and abroad, which will also likely impact the Canadian economy. However, it’s important not to panic and have a knee-jerk reaction. One of the other key rules when coming across a bear in the wilderness is not to run away, and that applies to investments. Take a step back, survey the environment, remember or revisit the plan, and stay on course.


Source: Kevin Headland, CIM C0-Chief Investment Strategist, Manulife Investment Management Macan Nia, CFA, Co-Chief Investment Strategist, Manulife Investment Management

Leave a Reply

Call the Right Direction Financial office